and that review at the top of this thread by Dan Jardine, stack him in the pissy critic section. he sounds most unfair. he probably gave the basket ball playing dog movie a better review.
when we come to these boards to post, we are posting on the person's WORK. i don't feel that we should have to concern ourselves with things in the person's PERSONAL life.
it's his WORK that we are posting on. the way he casts his personality on to paper.
if i were to crit jaime c. for writing a lousy welles article, and one of our members posted that i should no feel like that because jaime c. is a great guy, he donates to children's charities, he donates to blind indian charities, and he always helps old ladies to cross the street, that does not mean a hill of beans when i express my opinion about jaime c.'s WORK.
i was posting my opinion on what i though were nit-picky, pissy comments made by Jardine, and did not think that i needed to research his personal life before making up my mind about the comments i read.
Perhaps read a few more of his reviews before making a judgment.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest