A more positive assessment from Charles Morrow (on the "Nitrateville" Forum):
What I can now report is that the wish expressed by Lokke Heiss at the end of the piece—that is, a desire to experience a “re-purposing” of Welles’ material for an actual performance of William Gillette’s play—was accomplished last week at NYC’s Film Forum. I was fortunate enough to attend one of two performances of Too Much Johnson, the play, accompanied by the prologues created by Welles and his Mercury Theatre team over seventy-five years ago. The uncut material shown at Pordenone was, under the supervision of Bruce Goldstein, edited by William Hohauser into an approximation of what Welles might have intended. That’s subject to debate, of course, but to my eye it appeared that the takes used were the best available, arranged in a way that made sense. The prologues certainly went over well with the audience, and seemed to be a very close approximation of what was originally planned. The filmed sections were a blast, and while I especially enjoyed seeing Joseph Cotten caper about on rooftops like a silent clown, I’d have to say that Edgar Barrier practically stole the show.
It was a delightful evening. Something like 20% of it was comprised of the Welles film footage, while the other 80% was a semi-staged reading of William Gillette’s play, adapted and directed by Allen Lewis Rickman (perhaps best known for his acting role on Boardwalk Empire), who also appeared in the show. The cast was spirited; they knew how to play farce, and they played it to the hilt. The performance came off smoothly for the most part, but at one point when an actor missed a cue, they turned it into a joke, got a laugh, and rolled on without missing a beat. There was no scenery as such, but everyone was in costume, which helped set the antic mood.
Not much else to say, except that I hope the producers are able to do more with this project, i.e. take it to the next level and get it staged again, on a bigger scale if possible. More people should be able to see this.
Thanks to Colmena for the link to the Lokke Heiss blog entry:
https://lokkeheiss.wordpress.com/2014/0 ... on-welles/