Mr. Arkadin on DVD soon
- Jeff Wilson
- Wellesnet Advanced
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Wed May 30, 2001 7:21 pm
- Location: Detroit
- Contact:
-
97-1086573686
This is great news. Gary Tooze from DVD Beaver posted the following information (directly from Jonathan Rosenbaum):
'It will be a three-disc set including the Corinth version of the film (with a commentary by James Naremore and myself), CONFIDENTIAL REPORT, and a new edit by Stefan Droessler (of the Munich Film Archives) that will draw material from a variety of sources. Each version will have separate liner notes--by me, Francois Thomas, and Stefan, respectively--and I believe the set will also include some radio shows and a reprint of the novel (although there's new and more conclusive evidence, that will be cited, that Welles didn't write the latter).'
'It will be a three-disc set including the Corinth version of the film (with a commentary by James Naremore and myself), CONFIDENTIAL REPORT, and a new edit by Stefan Droessler (of the Munich Film Archives) that will draw material from a variety of sources. Each version will have separate liner notes--by me, Francois Thomas, and Stefan, respectively--and I believe the set will also include some radio shows and a reprint of the novel (although there's new and more conclusive evidence, that will be cited, that Welles didn't write the latter).'
- jaime marzol
- Wellesnet Legend
- Posts: 1091
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2001 3:24 am
As one of the people who benefitted from Fredric's trading largesse, let me say that the Corinth version is definitely the one to have, well until we see this new restoration from Stefan.
Not wishing to sound unduly pessimistic, especially as I am incredibly excited by this 3 version announcement by Rosenbaum, but has this been confirmed by anyone at Criterion? Where does the Rosenbaum quote come from exactly, apart from Gary at DVD Beaver (a great site by the way).
Either way, when this does become available, I will definitely set out a whole Saturday just to go through every bit of whatever Criterion puts out!!
Not wishing to sound unduly pessimistic, especially as I am incredibly excited by this 3 version announcement by Rosenbaum, but has this been confirmed by anyone at Criterion? Where does the Rosenbaum quote come from exactly, apart from Gary at DVD Beaver (a great site by the way).
Either way, when this does become available, I will definitely set out a whole Saturday just to go through every bit of whatever Criterion puts out!!
Watched Confidential Report :angry: the other the night - wonderfully done, freaky, deaky! :p it's quite a jump stylistically from his previous stuff - I can see elements of Lady from Shanghai being pushed further(this whole film noir thing that gets all surreal with poetico-romantic existencial musings
), the whole fluid, proto-cinema verité look - and its subsequent influence on TOE. All the truncations are bothersome, though - The motivations for Arkadin's death seem pretty unconvincing - the Wellesian structure and rhythm do seem pretty compromised, lots of clumsy-looking abrupt cutting with various story inconsistencies - Paola Mori is stunning - I like all the fairy tale/myth references - He would look like Neptune - The identity of your father is uncertain, the Ogre, the castle, Frog and Scorpion and friendship fables, Raina=Queen, etc... I can't wait to see the new restored version...
...and blest are those whose blood and judgment are so well commingled, that they are not a pipe for fortune's finger to sound what stop she please. Give me that man that is not passion's slave, and I will wear him in my heart's core...
- jaime marzol
- Wellesnet Legend
- Posts: 1091
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2001 3:24 am
For a movie that I initially didn't care for, I can't wait for the Criterion release. Maybe it's just me, but too bad they didn't include the spanish version as well. I mean not including the pub domain version is one thing. But in the spanish version, besides being in spanish, Welles actually filmed certain scenes with two different actresses. That's got to be worth something. JMO
- Jeff Wilson
- Wellesnet Advanced
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Wed May 30, 2001 7:21 pm
- Location: Detroit
- Contact:
I think it's a case of how far is too far before going overboard with the release. Three versions of a film like ARKADIN is already a lot to the casual fan. I guarantee you there will be reviews that ask why Criterion bothered to go as far as they did. I'm amazed they're providing three versions, to be honest. Criterion have certainly gone the extra mile in providing the Corinth-owned cut as well as the Munich restoration, so they certainly deserve some credit for that. Including the Harry Lime show and the novel, should that happen, will be nice (and necessary) touches as well. I fully expected to only get CONFIDENTIAL REPORT with minimal extras, so anything more than that is a bonus.
Return to “Mr. Arkadin, The Trial, The Immortal Story”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

